The Supernatural Wine Company

Note: The owner or a representative of this business has not yet completed the verification process

4.6

( 8 reviews )

Wine Bars $$

249 Centre St, New York, NY 10013, United States

The Supernatural Wine Company is a brand known for its exceptional wine collections. Established as La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels, the company has a reputation for offering a diverse range of wines that cater to different tastes. With a focus on natural wines, this company prides itself on its commitment to sustainability and promoting environmentally friendly practices. Their offerings include an extensive wine list, as well as a range of snacks, making it the perfect place for a night out with friends or a romantic evening. The Supernatural Wine Company also places emphasis on providing top-notch customer service, which has resulted in a loyal customer base. If you are looking for a unique wine experience, The Supernatural Wine Company is the perfect destination.

Amenities and More

Accepts reservations
Credit cards
Debit cards
NFC mobile payments
Outdoor seating
LGBTQ+ friendly
Food
Cozy
Trendy
Food at bar
Takeout
Transgender safespace
Upscale

Reviews

4.6/5

8 reviews

5 stars

4 stars

3 stars

2 stars

1 stars

Philip james

March 22, 2024

I attended a new year's night as I was invited by a friend who works here (disclaimer given) to a themed space party. The decor was nicely done and everybody was dressed up accordingly. I was happy to see people take it seriously and was told the establishment does hold regular programming. I was introduced to the crew who were all a nice set of people. Given they had a show to run, we said our pleasantries and off they went making other people merry. Let my friend do the ordering. There was an event menu. We first got oysters and some skewers, both of which were nice and tasty. The star of the night was the dessert shaped like an egg shell with a wine jelly. The live dj and music was popping and we both danced and enjoyed the music. So with drinks and two appetizers and one dessert and the music/theme was a night well spent.

Dana mccombs

March 22, 2024

Came here on a Friday night, so it was pretty busy. Was quite loud, so pretty hard to have convos across the table. The wine was unique and very good, but the super French beef tartare was a little too salty for my preference. We also got the basque cheesecake which was quite good. The sauvignon blanc I tried was very fruity and really nice. The pinot noir had a strong earthy smell, but I enjoyed the taste.

Shannon martin

March 22, 2024

If you’re interested in getting a glass of wine than this is the place for you. They have a huge wine list, and it’s a very cozy spot. The staff is really helpful and not pretentious about it. They even have a cute “guess the surprise wine” glass for a prize. We got the charcuterie board which was great.

Dominick reale

March 22, 2024

Nice wine bar in Manhattan! Note: if you made a reservation do try to make it on time. We were running around five minutes late and that nearly cost us the reservation as this spot is busy! The wine selection is pretty extensive, though the food menu items are more limited. We ordered a meat and cheese board which ended up being quite tasty, however it was definitely on the pricier side. Overall ambience is pleasant, there’s candles and boppy music. This is a nice spot for a date, or a girls night out in my opinion, but I don’t see myself returning regularly.

Yousef sahli

March 22, 2024

An upscale wine bar with a very comprehensive wine list, skewed French. Selection by glass is very good too. The burned basque cheesecake was good, but I like when it is more burnt outside. The cheese portion in a cheese plate is smaller than i expected. There is plenty of place and it was 50% full on Saturday night after 8pm so we enjoyed a non-crowded boho ambiance.

Sarah lujan

March 22, 2024

My favourite kind of restaurant experience: we didn't look at the menu once - the servers and bartenders drove the experience simply by asking questions and making recommendations. Had a cheese platter and a couple of glasses of wine. Lovely experience.

Cathryn ory

March 22, 2024

Great place great little Parisian wine bar. Just wish there was more food to nibble on while enjoying glasses of wine

Geri waggoner

March 22, 2024

Hands down, this is the very best wine bar in the city, with a wine list only comparable to top restaurants in Paris. If you want to experience wines from the top wineries, this place is the perfect destination to go. I had a second visit, and once again, I had a blast. Malcolm, the sommelier, has always been so attentive, welcoming, and friendly, with extensive knowledge about wine. The food pairing suggestions were also spot on.